Shay Deeter

“Working with Shay was a great experience from start to finish. She was extremely professional and took the time to walk me through the entire selling process, which made everything stress-free. She created a strong listing, priced my home spot-on, and we were able to sell in just over 30 days. I’m very grateful for her expertise and would gladly recommend her.”

“Shay is a dream realtor! She got our house sold in 37 days at a very attractive price in a slow real estate market! Shay meet with us and listen to our concerns regarding selling our family home. She understood our home’s value, educated us on the current market and helped price our home competitively. She put together an extensive marketing plan which included excellent professional photography including drone shots, videos and lifestyle montages posted on social media, as well as did open houses and a broker open house. She’s an excellent communicator and negotiator. She has a vast network within the industry and strong relationships with other realtor and vendors. Don’t list your house without interviewing Shay! You won’t be disappointed!”

“Shay is an exceptional realtor! She went out of her way to accommodate my needs and timeline, and she constructed the perfect deal--one I thought might be impossible. She made sure every detail was handled with care and professionalism, and gave me complete confidence throughout the entire process. I highly recommend working with Shay for your real estate needs. She exceeded every expectation, and I will absolutely continue using her for all of my future real estate transactions.”

“Shay is an exceptional realtor! She went out of her way to accommodate my needs and timeline, and she constructed the perfect deal--one I thought might be impossible. She made sure every detail was handled with care and professionalism, and gave me complete confidence throughout the entire process. I highly recommend working with Shay for your real estate needs. She exceeded every expectation, and I will absolutely continue using her for all of my future real estate transactions.”

“Working with Shay was an amazing experience from start to finish. Her deep local knowledge truly set her apart — she knows the neighborhoods inside and out, from school districts to the best local spots. She guided me through every step of the process with professionalism, patience, and care. I always felt supported and informed, and she went above and beyond to make sure I found the perfect home. If you’re looking for someone who really understands the area and puts her clients first, Shay is the one to call!”

“Shay goes above and beyond to make sure you are happy. She does not make you feel rushed while viewing homes and provides suggestions or things one can do in unique spaces in a home. She kept in contact with us during the buying process, very knowledge and professional. I highly recommend her to anyone wanting to work with a dedicated realtor”

“Shay took care of my new home purchase 2 years ago and she’s still helping family members now as well. We love her service, professionalism and genuine care.”

“I spoke Shay Deeter a few years ago prior to my move to Florida. It took me over 2 years to relocate to Florida. Once I got here, I started looking for lots with Shay. After finding my perfect lot, I used Synergy Homes for my builder. I viewed other builders with Shay, but I liked a model that Synergy had and was able to change items in the floor plan that I wanted. Working with Shay was the best, she a terrific realtor, always on top of things, answered all my questions, and was always there to help me navigate the whole process. Of course, I will always recommend Shay to anyone looking for a realtor!”

“I met Shay over 2 years ago when I was looking to relocate to PSL, FL. It took a while but I'm finally here as of September '24. Shay found a perfect lot in a great location, and I settled on it in the beginning of January 2025. I choose Synergy Homes for my home builder. The slab was poured in February. The build went very quickly, and it was finished the end of June. I love working with Shay - she's the BEST, always on top of everything, responds very quickly to all my questions, and I'll recommend her to anyone looking for a great person and realtor!”

“I give her five stars and beyond! I have bought and sold using Shay and was totally satisfied on all three occasions. She makes you feel as if you are her most important client and goes above and beyond to make sure you are happy with your final decisions. She demonstrates this with expert communication , knowledge, professionalism and genuine concern for her clients. I highly recommend her to family, friends and to anyone wanting to work with the best realtor in the business!”

“Shay, It’s truly an amazing realtor agent to work with. At times, you may not want to hear what she have to say and selling the house with the price you think you want and the actual pricing of the home. I am so happy my husband and I took some time and took her suggestions to sell our two homes with her and purchase our new home. It’s very difficult to find a hard-working and honest Shay.”

“I met Shay about 2 years ago when I was looking to relocate to PSL, FL. It took a while but I'm finally here as of September '24. Shay found a lot, great location, and I settled on it in the beginning of January '25. I went to Synergy Homes with Shay and will have Synergy for my home builder. I love working with Shay - she's the best, always on top of everything, responds very quickly to all my questions, and I'll recommend her to anyone looking for a great person and realtor!”

“I met Shay for about 2 years ago when I was looking to relocate to PSL, FL. It took a while but I'm finally here as of September '24. Shay found a lot, great location, and I settled on it in the beginning of January '25. I went to Synergy Homes with Shay and will have Synergy for my home builder. I love working with Shay - she's the best, always on top of everything, responds very quickly to all my questions, and I'll recommend her to anyone looking for a great person and realtor!”

“Shay was an outstanding partner in helping me purchase a property in Florida. She researched several properties and found a great property that met the requirements for my 1031 exchange. Since I am not a Florida resident, she sent me numerous videos of properties to evaluate until we came up with the best property for the price. The price she negotiated was at least $15,000 under the initial listed price. She also arranged for the inspections and made the purchase extremely easy. Once the purchase was complete, she sent me suggestions for contractors to make the few repairs and updates that were needed. Shay is very knowledgeable about the current market and guided me step by step through the whole process. I would highly recommend Shay to anyone needing a top real estate agent that does excellent work and has a wonderful personality.”

“Shay was the epitome of professionalism!”

“Great and pleasant experience, Shay was involved in every step of the way. Helped facilitate many things for us. Stayed in touch with all parties involved during the process Highly recommended.”

“Shay is an exceptional professional who is truly dedicated to her clients! Will highly recommend her to all my friends and family. She made the process of buying a new home so easy and her expertise made it a smooth transaction. She invests her time and efforts to make sure you are happy with your decision. She was an ideal agent!”

“Shay is a wonderful realtor. She is very knowledgeable and honest and truly helps the process of buying and selling a home not feel like a huge burden. She is very kind and always checks in with her clients. Absolutely recommend!”

“Shay is an exceptional professional who is dedicated to her clients. Highly recommend her to all my friends and family. She made the process of buying a new home so easy and her expertise made it a smooth transaction. She is understanding and very patient which as an elder I truly appreciated. She really invests herself in making sure you are happy with your decision. Outstanding agent!!”

“Shay was amazing throughout the entire process of buying and selling my home as a first time buyer. She carefully explained all the necessary details to help us secure great deals. She was honest and quick and always checked on us. Would absolutely recommend her expertise!”

“We received the best guidance and support throughout the whole process. Her expertise and professionalism are exceptional and we are very thankful for that. Highly recommend!”

“shay was the best to work with. she was so patient showing us many properties. she was so on top of everything and really helped us out a lot when we had to fly home to maryland for a death in our family and it was the day of our settlement so she filled in for us and did the walk through the property the day before settlement and represented us at the settlement which was amazing. could not have met a better real estate agent and a wonderful person! so willing to help!”

“I was very fortunate to have Shay reach out to me when I inquired about a house online. Shay gave me the resources I needed to start the process of buying my first home. For every house I showed interest in she would research and gather additional info to share with me. Always kept me updated throughout the process and never hesitated to call. I never felt that I was being pressured into buying anything. She would explain the steps thoroughly and as many times as I needed, for someone that’s slow to pick things up like myself, it helped a lot. She also has previous experience on construction which came in useful when looking at houses, she would point things out that would cost money in repairs or could reduce costs with insurance. I highly recommend Shay for anyone looking to buy a house in the Treasure Coast.”

“Shay was professional, courteous, and very knowledgeable of the area. Very communicative, and helped me negotiate down the price of the home I was buying. She was present for the home inspection, appraisal, and final walk through since I was at work in a different state. Always kept me updated during the entire process.”

“Shay Deeter is the best, she went over and above to help us get what we wanted in a home, I recommend her highly, we’re happy and lucky to have had Shay as our Realtor!!”

“Shay is an excellent Realtor. More importantly Shay is a very good person. She is patient and willing to do whatever is needed to get you the right property. We have brought many homes over the years and we believe that our experience with Shay is at the very top.”

“Shay did an excellent job helping us with our seasonal rental. She was very friendly, responsive, knowledgeable, and detail-oriented. Working in the industry, I know that rentals are not always the highest priority for seasoned real estate agents. Shay was professional throughout and gave us the highest level of attention, meeting us on a Sunday afternoon to give us access to the unit, answer our questions, and help us get oriented to our new seasonal location in sunny Florida!”

“Shay Deeter is the best! She came to us after another agent from another agency failed. Shay was constantly working to find our ideal spot, contacting us at 7:00 am and 10:00 p.m. Shay made us feel as if we were the most important people to her and did not stop even after finding us the right home. If you want the best, call Shay Deeter.”

“Shay was truly the best realtor we could’ve asked for. We wouldn’t be in our dream home without her! She always had our best interest at heart and made sure to find us the perfect home. We will continue to work with her with all of our future properties!”

“Shay is an incredible realtor. Very knowledgeable, respectful, goes out of her way to find you what you are looking for when there's not much around in your price range. Shay helped my husband and I find our home in an area that was very new to us. 1yr later we love the area and the neighborhood. Shay even gives you a call 1yr later asking how everything is going. Now that is what I call a fantastic realtor. You will not go wrong working with Shay. She is amazing ”

“My Husband and I had an excellent experience with Shay Deeter Realtor, Shay helped us find the perfect home, she made the process easy, she is knowledgeable responsive and very professional,She was very patient with us and kept searching to find us what we were looking for, Now everyday my family gets to enjoy the blessing of a wonderful home. Please contact Shay Deeter Realtor if you would like to purchase a home or selling.”

“Shay has assisted us with the purchase of two properties and was a pleasure to work with from point of first contact through closing, and she was just as available after closing if we had any questions or needed any referrals for local contractors, handypeople, or professional services. Shay is a consumate professional with a deep knowledge and understanding of the local market as well as a broad view of the larger state, national and global real estate markets and how they affect us locally. Most importantly to us, Shay genuinely cares about her clients and it shows. Her communication skills are amazing and she made herself available to us at all times. If she couldn't speak with us immediately, she would let us know and call us back as soon as possible. Her calm demeanor and kindness helped smooth sometimes ruffled feathers and actually single-handedly saved one of the deals with her great mediation skills. We can 100% recommend Shay for any and all of your real estate needs, whether buying or selling. She's a true gem! Sincerely, Dawn & John”

“We had such a wonderful experience with Shay. We sold our home in Georgia much more quickly than we expected and we had only casually been looking for a new home in Jupiter. I let Shay know we were in a huge hurry and she really went to work! She showed numerous homes to my daughter since we were not able to travel. She was so helpful, knowledgeable and kind. She really went above and beyond what I would expect of a realtor. I would highly recommend her to help buy or sell your next home.”

“Shay was outstanding from the first time I communicated with her. She answered all my questions and was immediately responsive to texts and calls. Throughout the process of my purchase she was super patient and always explained what was happening at the time and what the next steps would be. I would highly recommend Shay to anyone who is looking to purchase. She as an absolute pleasure to work with!”

“We could not be happier with our Shay as our realtor. The knowledge and expertise Shay provided helped a great deal with guiding the purchase of our new home. Highly recommended!”

“Shay went far above what I expected to make this sale happen. She showed homes to our daughter since we couldn’t be there. She answered a million questions and always seemed to have time for us. I would recommend her to anyone and everyone. She is a top notch realtor and a patient and kind person. Loved working with her!”

“I first met Shay through a cold call. She was quick and responsive in answering a general request for information. I did not know at the time but I hit the jackpot with Shay. Our client/realtor relationship was a long one (at least 9 months) we really got to know Shay and how she does business along the way. I was new to the area and didn't know anyone or anything, she helped me with local knowledge and information. Through a long process of finding a perfect forever home that we absolutely love, Shay was there to answer any question and to offer sound and intelligent advice though every step of the process. She offered advice when asked, and stepped aside when appropriate. She would check in with us in a timely manner, but never too much or overbearing. She had loads of advice and contacts outside of general real estate questions and every single contact she recommended has worked out wonderfully. I would use Shay again in a heartbeat, but I never want to move out of my home, she's the best. Thank you Shay!”

“I recently had the pleasure of working with Shay as my realtor, and I can confidently say that it was an exceptional experience. From start to finish, she went above and beyond to ensure that my needs were met and that I found the perfect home. One of the things that stood out to me most about Shay was her exceptional communication skills. She was always available to answer any questions or concerns I had, and she kept me informed throughout the entire home buying process. Shay also took the time to understand my preferences and needs, which made it easier for her to find properties that aligned with my wants and needs. Shay's professionalism and expertise were also evident throughout the process. She was knowledgeable about the local real estate market and was able to provide valuable insights and advice. Shay's attention to detail was also exceptional, and she ensured that every aspect of the home buying process was handled efficiently and effectively. Overall, I highly recommend Shay as a realtor. She is dedicated, knowledgeable, and committed to providing exceptional service to her clients. If you are looking for a realtor who will go above and beyond to help you find your dream home, Shay is the realtor for you.”

“Working with Shay was a real pleasure. After this venture of purchasing our first new home in Port St. Lucie Shay became family and was no longer just our agent. She went above and beyond for us and is still reaching out trying to help even after the deal has been closed. We are thankful for her knowledge she brings with her and her experience of course. It was a very smooth transaction considering we did a lot from Canada. Thank you Shay.”

“The first time I met Shay was by phone several months before I was actually ready to buy. I live in NY and of course she’s in Fla. We spent a great deal of time on the phone for many weeks, which was always very informative and fun. By the time the weekend came to actually meet she knew exactly what we needed and was ready to go. We were limited with time and in 2 days we found what we were looking for. She is a dedicated and wonderful person, who goes above and beyond what’s necessary. Shay not only helped us find what we were looking for, she became a good friend too. If you are lucky enough to work with her you won’t be disappointed!!!”

“I have never used the same realtor more than once, I have used Shay for buying & selling for 3 residence. Her dedication & commitment to her clients is remarkable. She is very reliable she is there through the entire process of buying & selling. I choose the best agent to work with very enjoyable process.”

“She is very professional & detail oriented. She is involved in every step of the buying & selling process. We used her for both selling & buying. The process of selling our house Shay coordinate the open house, we got many offers from the open house. In the process of buying it’s a new construction Shay gets updates from construction an sales in the next steps of the building process. We couldn’t ask for a better agent.”

“Buying my house was an awesome experience! I can't say enough abut Shay's help and expertise. She quickly identified my priorities and what I was looking for and didn't waste my time with homes that didn't fit. I am buying remote which, in this case, simply did not matter. Once I went down and selected a house, Shay took care of everything that I couldn't be there for. She even showed up for the home inspection! She provided mortgage options, inspection options, settlement and insurance options and I got to pick who to work with and shop and compare. Even after settlement, she continues to support, providing immediate answers for anything I need for when I move in. She even provided guides and material for folks like me who are new to the Port St. Lucie, FL area. I highly recommend reaching out to Shay and letting her assist with you finding your dream home in such a beautiful location. Thank you, Shay!”

“Shay was terrific! She took the stress out of buying a home by making sure everything was in order and QUICKLY taken care of! She got us the home of our dreams, and I would highly recommend her to any of my family and friends.”

“I was so pleased to find Shay. I was not having good results with the previous agent as she just didn;t listen to my needs or budget. Shay lsitened and we made no goose chases . Found my go to place in realtively shore time. She was professional and yet very personable, warm and obviosly cared about my adventure to buy a new place. I absolutely would recommend her to anyone looking to find the right fit in purchasing a new home. She handled all the details that I wouldn't have expected but she made it seamless on every detail right to the closing!”

“Shay helped my husband and I move from another state and find the perfect home. She has been amazing through the entire process with her knowledge, time and support. Thank you Shay!!”

“To say Shay is a professional is an understatement. From the moment my husband and I spoke to her on an inquiry I made on a home, she became our agent. We were out of state buyers and she was extremely helpful in showing us properties via FaceTime, as well as putting in offers immediately, knowing time was of the essence in this competitive market. She was always in touch throughout the purchasing process and I loved that she was extremely knowledgable of the areas in which we were interested in purchasing our home and honestly, she was only a text message away, she always responded to me in a flash. When we found our home, Shay advised us through the process including a complete list of utility companies contact numbers, lists of insurance companies etc. She was right there til the end guiding us step by step with every detail! I highly recommend Shay as an agent and will recommend her to everyone I know.”

“We cannot recommend Shay highly enough….she works tirelessly, is persistent but not pushy, knows a lot about all the different neighborhoods in and around Stuart, and, as a bonus, is extremely nice, personable, and a pleasure to work with. Everything about our house purchase went smoothly. We hope to see her around the neighborhood!”

“Shay is a very nice person who will exceed your expectations. She is very knowledgeable about real estate in the area and will handle your needs in a very professional manner. She is very responsive with great communication skills. I would not hesitate to strongly recommend her to anyone. Thanks for an excellent lob, Shay!!”

“Shay is exceptional in communication from beginning to end. Moving to an area that is new to us, Shay provided her knowledge and help to make our transition comfortable. There is no doubt we will keep her as our agent for future transactions.”

“Shay was on top of things from the moment I messaged her. She kept us informed the entire time and made this process as smooth as possible for us. I would highly recommend her!”

“Shay is a pro at what she does. What helped me the most was her responsiveness to all my questions throughout the process. Buying this home in a new state, by myself challenged me and she was incredibly helpful with all of it.”

“Shannon Shay Deeter is very professional in her work, we get right track to get the process of buying house . Thank you for having shay to be part of purchase and cooperating to buy a house .”

“We are a family of 4 escaping CA for FL - Big Move! And we are first time home buyers. Shay is exactly what we were hoping to find for a realtor. She's full of up to date knowledge and good honest advice. Her communication is impeccable...her attitude is very pleasant. We feel blessed to have found an agent of her integrity. She made our experience of buying our first home, out of state, as stress-free as possible. Thank you a million times over Shay, we will definitely keep you in mind for any future real estate needs!”

“Fast and efficient with this fast market. Knows the area and listens to what you need. On point in every way and will definitely use her again! Thank you so much! Mr & Mrs Newbold”

“Shay deserves 10 stars!! Shay was very knowledgeable, kind, understanding, honesty she was amazing from our 1st phone call. She understood what I was looking for as I gave her a very broad area expanding 2 county's. She lined us up with 4 showings and we ended up loving our 3rd home. Shay stayed with us throughout the whole process and answered all our questions and even asking questions to our lender we didn't think of asking. She will stay in touch with you throughout the whole process. Shay was absolutely amazing and I highly recommend.”

“Shay has gone above and beyond to help find my perfect home. Due to conflicts, i was unable to be in person for some viewings. Shay took the time to provide vitual clips of those homes to help with my decision making. She is always on time and establish quick rapport with clients. I have no hesitation to recommend Shay to potential buyers.”

“Shay is an excellent realtor and made the entire home buying process simple and stress free! She quickly understood what we were looking for and helped us find the home we wanted in a competitive seller's market. She was very responsive, visited places quickly and was able to accommodate our difficult schedule. She is also well-connected and has been able to provide us with great contacts including painters, gardeners, and insurance brokers. We would recommend her without hesitation!”

“I would recommend Shay to everyone her dedication in working with clients speaks volume of her work integrity. She literally works 24/7 always available by email, phone, text & in person meeting. I have worked with many real estate agents in the past I haven’t crossed anyone like her. Truly the perfect agent.”

“Shay helped me sell vacant lots in Port Saint Lucie area. She knows this market very well and is well connected with builders. As soon as she started selling the property I got an offer. She was very responsive and straight forward. Shay provided useful guidance on market conditions, but remained open to my strategy. At the end I was very happy with the outcome of the transaction and would gladly work with her in the future.”

“Shay was very knowledgeable and amazing from day one. She was involved in every thing and continuously kept me updated throughout the process of buying my new home. I highly recommend her for any of your future selling or home purchases.”

“Shay is everything you would want in a Real Estate Professional. She has extensive knowledge of the real estate market in the region and is a smooth negotiator. Shay impressed me the most with her masterful process expertise and her immediate responsiveness to all my questions and inquires. Shay is a hard worker and makes you feel like you are her only client.”

“Shay was outstanding and exceptional when it came to our new real estate purchase. She perfectly lead the process of our land purchase and repeatedly went above and beyond to ensure that we were satisfied whole heartedly. I will continue to work with Shay for any and all future home and land purchases/sales in the Florida area. I highly recommend Shay as a realtor.”

“In our search for property in FL, talked with different Realtors who didn't know the difference between navigable water and ponds. Then connected with Shay. She was very professional, knowledge of areas we were interested in; did know what navigable water was, warm and caring. Working with her through the process of purchasing our dream home has been a real pleasure. Not just in the search but after closing as well. A wonderful new friend was found.”

“I highly recommend Shay as a realtor. Very thorough, and smart. Our house was sold within days of signing a contract. The whole process was great!! If anyone is in need of selling their home please contact Shay, she will help you buy or sell your real estate, She answered every question and made us feel at ease with the sale of our house.”

“Shay and the Atlantic Shores office made the home buying process easy. My buying needs were matched with suitable homes and Shay went out of her way to make virtual tours possible. Shay was great to work with and it was a positive experience from start to finish.”

“We can't speak highly enough of our experience with Shay Deeter. We met with a couple of realtors before Shay, but we knew instantly that she was the one for us. She is very attentive, caring and hands-on she really helped to take the pressure off of us all the way to closing and even after closing to make sure we were OK. Very detailed oriented and even gave us an engraved cutting board with our names as keepsake. We feel we've have gained a friend.”

“Shannon was very knowledgeable and responsible. She was able to answer all my questions in a timely manner and assisted me through the entire process. I am very happy that everything went according to plan. I would highly recommend Shannon and her team.”